A look at the gripping true crime tale in ‘woman of the hour’
Understanding the unique storytelling of Rodney Alcala’s saga
“Woman of the Hour,” now available on Netflix, unearths the chilling story of Rodney Alcala, a serial killer who shockingly won ”The Dating Game” during his murderous rampage in 1978. Screenwriter Ian McDonald blends true crime with nuanced storytelling, aiming to make the narrative feel both necessary and resonant.
The challenge of true crime narrative
Writing for true crime often walks a fine line between capturing gripping drama and respecting real-life tragedies. For Ian McDonald, the task was to craft a story that felt **“necessary and useful”. He faced the inherent challenge of portraying Alcala—a killer often likened to Ted Bundy not only for his attractiveness but for his sinister duplicity.
But as McDonald insightfully points out, Alcala’s underlying threat was his ability to blend into society seamlessly. ”He was a chameleon,” notes McDonald, emphasizing how Alcala managed to hide behind a facade, exploiting societal norms and a culture that looked the other way.
Unveiling Alcala on the big screen
Directed by and starring Anna Kendrick as Cheryl, an actress on “The Dating Game,” the film has earned acclaim, debuting at the 2023 Toronto International Film Festival and swiftly topping Netflix’s most-watched list upon its October release.
Kendrick’s dual role offers an intriguing touch. Her involvement extends beyond acting, deeply influencing the film’s thematic development and narrative choices. Kendrick’s insight into portraying women’s coerced politeness even led to script adjustments, ensuring authenticity.
Depicting the victims’ perspective
Portraying the victims of Alcala’s gruesome acts posed another significant challenge. With estimates suggesting Alcala may have killed up to 130 people, selecting which interactions to depict required poignant sensitivity.
McDonald shares, “How you open and close a movie says so much about the film’s intentions thematically and has a massive dramatic impact.” The focus wasn’t just on the crimes, but on their revelation of the killer’s psychological landscape. Each scene needed to build upon the previous, shedding light on new facets of Alcala’s dark persona.
A balance of violence and sensitivity
Violence in true crime media can be controversial. McDonald and Kendrick approached recreating Alcala’s murders with deliberate caution. They strived to avoid gratuitous bloodshed, recognizing the pain and humanity of the real victims and their families. This decision mirrors a broader industry trend towards responsible storytelling, emphasizing integrity over sensationalism.
“Moments of violence were something I really agonized over,” explains McDonald. Unlike purely fictional depictions a la Fincher’s “Seven,” this film bore the weight of real-life consequences and memories. It was essential to convey the darkness Alcala represented without overshadowing the narrative.
Nuanced character interactions
One scene particularly stands out, reflecting McDonald’s empathetic screenplay and Kendrick’s focused direction. When Cheryl and Alcala leave a bar and she senses something amiss, the tension mounts as Alcala stalks her. This moment epitomizes the subtle terror experienced by many women, brought to life through careful storytelling.
McDonald drew on his experiences and the testimonies of female friends to illustrate these scenarios authentically. Understanding that his perspective as a man differs, he actively sought out stories of women who had felt threatened on dates, ensuring the script carried genuine emotional weight.
Enhancing authenticity through collaborative effort
The collaboration between McDonald and Kendrick emphasized honesty and respect for lived experiences. In portraying a hitchhiker’s interaction with Alcala, Kendrick’s feedback was instrumental in refining the character’s portrayal to reflect realistic survival tactics women often employ—highlighting the delicate balancing act women must navigate when facing potential danger.
By intertwining these real-life nuances into the script, they aimed to present a story that resonates deeply while maintaining a firm grip on the terrifying truth.
Watch the “Woman of the Hour” trailer here.
Remember to share your thoughts and follow us for more in-depth film analyses.
Creating a true crime story that is both gripping and respectful requires a deft touch. “Woman of the Hour” navigates this balance, offering a compelling examination of Rodney Alcala’s sinister reality while respecting the victims’ stories.