Tyla’s album faces Grammy controversy as it moves from R&B to pop

A Change in Category Shakes Up Grammy Predictions

Earlier this year, Tyla made history by winning the first-ever Grammy for best African music performance. However, her musical journey took an unexpected turn as her debut album was re-categorized from R&B to pop for the 2025 Grammy Awards. This shift has sparked debate and left many questioning the decision.

The Controversial Decision

Tyla’s self-titled debut album was originally submitted for best R&B album. Nevertheless, the Recording Academy’s R&B screening committee, comprised of artists, producers, and songwriters highly respected in the R&B genre, decided to shift her album to the best pop vocal album category. This move has left fans and critics puzzled, especially considering the album’s deep roots in Southern African genres like Amapiano, Afrobeats, and R&B.

Competing With Pop Giants

If Tyla’s album secures a nomination in the pop category, she will face stiff competition. The pop category already hosts some heavyweights, including:

• Taylor Swift’s The Tortured Poets Department
• Billie Eilish’s Hit Me Hard and Soft
• Sabrina Carpenter’s Short N’ Sweet
• Ariana Grande’s Eternal Sunshine
• Chappell Roan’s The Rise and Fall of a Midwest Princess

The prospect of going head-to-head with such prominent names highlights the gravity of the situation.

The Case for Progressive R&B

It’s worth noting that Tyla’s album might have been more fitting in the best progressive R&B album category. This specific category was established to honor R&B-based albums that integrate various genres, from rap to dance to pop. For instance, SZA’s SOS won this category earlier this year, setting a precedent for inclusion of diverse sounds. Given the eclectic nature of Tyla’s tracks, many argue that this would have been a more appropriate placement.

Chart-Topping Hits

The success of Tyla’s album on the charts further cements its popularity. Six tracks from the album have landed on Billboard’s Hot R&B Songs chart. The lead single “Water” not only conquered the No. 1 spot on the R&B chart but also reached No. 7 on the Hot 100 chart, and maintained a phenomenal 51-week run atop the U.S. Afrobeats Songs chart.

“Water” exemplifies her global impact, winning the inaugural best African music performance Grammy. Such achievements add weight to the argument that her album should reflect its multifaceted genre influences.

Collaborations and Musical Fusion

Tyla’s debut also boasts impressive collaborations with artists like Travis Scott, Tems, Gunna, Becky G, and Skillibeng. These partnerships bring a rich blend of sounds and styles, resonating strongly with diverse audiences. Each track demonstrates an intricate fusion of genres, making the pop categorization even more contentious.

Historical Context and Comparisons

The decision to reassign Tyla’s album brings to mind previous Grammy classification controversies. For example, Lizzo’s Cuz I Love You won best progressive R&B album in 2020, despite its blend of R&B, dance, and rap elements. Similarly, Tommy Richman’s viral TikTok hit “Million Dollar Baby” remained in the rap category even though its submission sparked debates, owing to Richman’s claims of not identifying strictly as a hip-hop artist.

These examples highlight a recurring pattern of genre-fluid artists facing challenges in categorization. The Grammys’ evolving approach to genre definitions generates ongoing debates within the industry.

Upcoming Grammy Milestones

As the Grammys prepare for the next phase, first-round voting for the 2025 awards has just concluded. Nominations will be announced on November 8, with final voting scheduled between December 12 and January 3. The grand event will be broadcasted live on February 2 from the Crypto.com Arena in Los Angeles, promising an exciting lineup and potentially even more surprises.

The unfolding narrative around Tyla’s album and its Grammy categorization raises critical questions about genre classification and artist recognition. As fans and industry insiders await the final nominations, the discussion about Tyla’s musical journey continues to captivate audiences worldwide.

Stay engaged with the latest updates by sharing this article on social media and following our platform for more intriguing stories on the music industry’s biggest events and transformations.