‘A nice Indian boy’ review: Bollywood dreams in a quirky romantic comedy
Unveiling unexpected love
The romantic comedy “A Nice Indian Boy” takes an unexpected angle on love stories by incorporating a queer narrative into a genre that often deals with Indian social mores and cross-generational family politics. The narrative centers around Naveen, played by Karan Soni, who would typically be seen as an ideal match—good-looking, articulate, and a doctor. However, the twist here is that Naveen is gay and searching for his suitor, who turns out to be Jay, a white man deeply immersed in Indian culture.
Traditional tropes with a twist
“A Nice Indian Boy” adheres closely to traditional romcom templates while sprinkling in unique elements. From their serendipitous meeting in a Hindu temple to the quintessential second-act breakup and colorful wedding dance, the film is a comforting journey through classic romance territory. The film leverages Bollywood’s grand gestures and cites the ‘90s classic “Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge” for its happy ending. This layering of predictable yet comforting elements positions the film as both familiar and fresh, particularly for queer characters of color—a rarity in this genre.
An endearing family dynamic
The film opens with the wedding of Naveen’s sister, Arundhathi, to an eligible Indian man, representing an aspirational goal for their traditional immigrant parents. Naveen, who remains closeted to his family about his personal life, feels a sense of inadequacy and wonders if he will ever find such societal approval.
However, as the story advances, we see significant changes. Naveen, still single and deeply engrossed in his profession, finds solace and a potential life partner in Jay. Jay, a photographer with a deep respect and practice of Hindu traditions, appears to be an ideal match whose cultural affinities align with what Naveen’s family would value, making the budding relationship a unique twist in this cross-cultural narrative.
Crossing the meet-the-parents stage
The film excels in exploring Naveen’s anxieties as he contemplates introducing Jay to his family. The script shines in these moments, highlighting how Naveen’s preconceptions about his parents might be unfounded. His parents, particularly his father, might not be as traditional as Naveen assumes, while Arundhathi’s life isn’t the epitome of a conventional marriage.
“A Nice Indian Boy” offers a nuanced look at a middle-class Indian American family navigating cultural transitions between two worlds. Zarna Garg’s portrayal of a protective mother, waiting to be allowed into her son’s life, brings depth and emotion to the storyline, making it both gently funny and moving.
The romance that almost makes it
While the familial exploration is compelling, the romantic aspect feels somewhat less satisfying. Jay, played by Jonathan Groff, is depicted with unwavering grace, maturity, and niceness that makes him appear almost too perfect. The film gives us scant insight into Jay’s own life beyond his relationship with Naveen, making some of the romantic milestones feel a bit rushed. Their chemistry, though genuine, sometimes glosses over complex issues with simple cinematic solutions, such as a musical number or a shared moment in the kitchen.
Yet, this is the nature of mainstream romantic comedies, and “A Nice Indian Boy” embraces these clichés with an endearing sincerity and humor. The film’s final sequence, filled with energetic choreography and vivid colors, captures the joy and extravagance of Indian weddings, while also demonstrating Jay’s observation to Naveen, “I think we’re all embarrassed by the bigness of love.” Through these layers of sincerity and humor, the film ultimately wins our hearts.
A refreshing addition to the genre
Director Roshan Sethi’s third feature is an exuberant, if somewhat formulaic, exploration of love, family, and identity. The film’s ability to combine Bollywood-inspired grandeur with a heartwarming queer love story sets it apart in the romantic comedy landscape.
By enriching the film with cultural references and heartfelt performances, “A Nice Indian Boy” offers a refreshing and important perspective, broadening the scope of queer representation in cinema. The film doesn’t just entertain but also opens a dialogue on cultural acceptance and the universality of love, making it a memorable watch.
Stay tuned for more insightful reviews and updates on your favorite films and TV shows. Connect with us on social media to keep the conversation going.