Delving into the mind of a political maestro: ‘Carville: Winning is everything, stupid’
Navigating the volatile landscape of politics has always been a risky endeavor, but capturing that in real-time for a documentary elevates the challenge to a whole new level. The landscape can shift dramatically between the start and end of production, testing the filmmaker’s ability to stay relevant.
In the spotlight is ”Carville: Winning is everything, stupid,” an intriguing and unfiltered portrait of James Carville, the larger-than-life Democratic political operative from Louisiana. Known affectionately and provocatively as “The Raging Cajun,” Carville’s blend of unabashed confidence and razor-sharp wit make him impossible to ignore.
Behind the scenes of the political spectacle
For director Matt Tyrnauer, the approach was clear: follow Carville through the tumultuous 2024 Presidential race, capturing his worries as early polls hinted at incumbent Joe Biden’s possible defeat by ex-President Donald Trump. Tyrnauer meticulously documents Carville’s growing skepticism about Biden’s ability to withstand the rigors of another term. These doubts existed well before they became mainstream chatter within the Democratic Party.
The shock of political reality
In May 2024, a pivotal moment arrives with an ABC/Washington Post poll showing Trump leading Biden. Carville’s raw reaction to the poll—“it knocked me right off my fucking horse”—is emblematic of his candid persona. This bombshell forces Carville to contemplate a radical plan: Biden should bow out without anointing a successor, leaving the choice up to a wide-open Democratic National Convention.
The documentary’s progression is a testament to Tyrnauer’s skill in capturing drama. Despite the unpredictable turns of real-world politics, the film crafts a narrative that feels both complete and compelling, ending with a jarring plot twist as Kamala Harris makes an unexpected appearance just before the credits roll.
Evolution of a kingmaker
“Carville: Winning is everything, stupid” does more than depict electoral drama; it tracks Carville’s evolution from political novice to one of America’s most formidable political strategists. Carville first gained national prominence as the chief campaign advisor to Bill Clinton during his iconic 1992 presidential run. George Stephanopoulos, an early assistant to Carville, highlights their shared roguish qualities, which undoubtedly aided them in weathering numerous scandals.
Carville’s strategy was revolutionary: distract from Clinton’s personal controversies by focusing on his potential to solve the country’s problems, a maneuver encapsulated by the famous phrase, “It’s the economy, stupid!” This slogan became a defining meme of the early ’90s, showcasing Carville’s knack for resonating with the public.
A unique relationship amidst political contrasts
Adding a human touch to the mix, Tyrnauer delves into Carville’s unexpected yet enduring relationship with Republican operative Mary Matalin. Their interplay of conflicting ideologies and mutual respect offers a poignant glimpse into a time when political disagreements did not preclude personal connections. It’s a powerful reminder of an era marked by civility, even in the face of stark ideological divides.
Controversial yet captivating
Carville’s own reflections suggest he is acutely aware of being perceived as a relic within the evolving political landscape. Criticizing the “woke silliness” of some progressives, he expresses concern that such extremism could alienate moderates and liberals alike. Despite facing backlash from Biden’s supporters for advocating his replacement, Carville remains unwavering in his conviction that winning is paramount.
Political consultant and commentator Paul Begala, underscoring Carville’s undeniable acumen, sums it up: Carville “is the smartest son of a bitch who’s ever done this for a living.” Despite the advancing years, Carville’s passion and skill in political maneuvering are as sharp as ever.
For those fascinated by the machinations of political strategy and the personalities that drive it, “Carville: Winning is everything, stupid” is a must-watch. Dive into the high-stakes world of political campaigns and get an intimate look at one of its most iconic figures.
Stay tuned for more insightful analyses and updates on the latest documentaries and political dramas.