A gripping tale of power and faith: ’Conclave’ review
Behind the Vatican walls: A thriller unfolds
If you think the American presidential election is unpredictable, wait until you witness the drama that ensues when the cardinals gather to elect a new pope in Conclave. Adapted from a novel, this film, directed by Edward Berger, takes on a different challenge after his work on ”All Quiet on the Western Front.” This intellectual thriller unravels like a murder mystery within the locked doors of the Domus Sanctae Marthae, where the College of Cardinals is sequestered. However, no one suspects foul play in the previous pope’s death.
The race for the papacy: Intrigue and ambition
Intrigues abound as the papabili—those considered next in line for the papacy, portrayed by formidable actors like Ralph Fiennes, Stanley Tucci, and John Lithgow—maneuver to secure their election. Conclave echoes Plato’s adage, “Only those who do not seek power are qualified to hold it,” featuring candidates who display a mix of self-effacing humility and ruthless ambition. Just when you think you have it all figured out, the film delivers one of the most satisfying twists in years, a Hail Mary that surprises and restores faith, at least for the disillusioned.
A reflection on the Catholic Church’s history
The Catholic Church has a checkered past when it comes to selecting popes, making it plausible to find venal, licentious, and even racist men among the contenders. The film doesn’t shy away from this reality, highlighting the Church’s stubborn sexism in contrast to other religions that have embraced female leaders. This imbalance is addressed by casting Isabella Rossellini as the all-seeing Sister Agnes, who knows when to hold her tongue and when to speak up.
Cardinal Lawrence: A conflicted leader
Ralph Fiennes delivers a quietly conflicted performance as Cardinal Lawrence, who reluctantly serves as the dean of the conclave. Lawrence is torn between devotion and doubt, a struggle that Fiennes portrays with subtlety and depth. In private conversations with Cardinal Bellini (Tucci), the papabile for whom he repeatedly casts his ballot, Lawrence admits to his crisis of faith. He is surprised to learn that the late pope had doubts as well, though his were about the future of the Church.
A thriller with depth and insight
Though Conclave plays like a thriller, complete with disorienting jump cuts and a tense string score, its true strength lies in its insights into the embattled institution. The film acknowledges the Church’s controversial past, including leaders who were former members of the Hitler Youth or those who covered up sex abuse cases. While it may not be as philosophically satisfying as “The Two Popes,” it articulates how the Church must evolve to remain relevant in a fast-changing world.
The voting process: A meticulous depiction
Berger is clearly fascinated by the pomp and protocol of the actual voting process, which takes place in the Sistine Chapel (or a convincing replica thereof). The film meticulously depicts how ballots are filled out, folded, and ceremoniously deposited into a large silver urn, then counted, bound, and burned. The public, never seen but always present, gathers beyond the walls, watching the chimney above the Sistine Chapel. Black smoke means no majority has been reached; white smoke signifies a new pope has been chosen.
A modern twist on an ancient ritual
During this fictional conclave, the cardinals find themselves staring out the Vatican windows at smoke rising from the city around them—an alarming twist on the solemn process. Terrorists are setting car bombs in the piazza outside, underscoring the stakes of the cardinals’ choice. Berger, though German, likely considered what Conclave has to say about contemporary politics. The cardinals are surrounded by division and must choose between unity and hate. Despite the despondency of Fiennes’ character, the unexpected resolution feels almost perfect, like an answered prayer.
Watch the trailer
For a closer look at this gripping film, check out the Conclave trailer.
Final thoughts
Conclave is a rare film that respects the audience’s intelligence while sneaking in a few surprises. It offers a compelling look at the inner workings of the Vatican and the complex characters who inhabit it. Whether you’re a cinema enthusiast, a TV series aficionado, or a music lover, this film provides a thought-provoking experience that will leave you pondering long after the credits roll.