Ron Howard’s ‘Eden’: A misanthropic journey into madness
A filmmaker’s eclectic journey
Ron Howard has always prided himself on his versatility as a filmmaker. Over the past four decades, he has explored a wide array of subjects, from mermaids and astronauts to firefighters and the Beatles. However, at the Toronto Film Festival premiere of his latest film, Eden, Howard declared that this movie stands apart from all his previous works. And he’s right, though perhaps not for the reasons he believes.
A tale of survival and madness
Eden, based on events that transpired a century ago on one of the Galápagos Islands, defies easy categorization. While it has been labeled a “thriller,” it feels more like a misanthropic survivalist tale—a blend of Robinson Crusoe and Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, with a touch of Nietzschean madness. For Howard, this film is indeed a departure, featuring elements of sex, murder, and animal slaughter. Yet, the most striking difference is not the eccentric subject matter but Howard’s apparent loss of his storytelling touch.
Characters lost in translation
From the outset, the film struggles with a fundamental question: If the characters are based on real historical figures, why do they feel so artificial? Jude Law, who recently delivered a stellar performance as an FBI agent in The Order, here descends into a caricature of Teutonic surliness as Friedrich Ritter, a German physician who has retreated to the isolated island of Floreana in the Galápagos Archipelago. It’s 1929, and the world is reeling from economic collapse. Ritter believes that the old order is doomed and that a new utopia can rise from its ashes. He is determined to be its architect.
A manifesto of madness
Ritter, driven by a messianic fervor, spends his days pounding away at a typewriter, drawing dark inspiration from Nietzsche. He envisions a new future but seems to have already given up on it. His cynical bluster and loss of faith in humanity appear to be the real reasons for his self-imposed exile. His wife, Dora (Vanessa Kirby), accompanies him, and together they resemble a debauched Adam and Eve. Their relationship is fraught with conflict, and their utopian dream seems doomed from the start.
The unwelcome disciples
The arrival of another couple, Heinz Wittmer (Daniel Brühl) and his wife, Margaret (Sydney Sweeney), further complicates matters. They have come to Floreana, inspired by Ritter’s accounts, hoping to join his movement. They bring their son, Harry, who suffers from tuberculosis, hoping the island air will cure him. However, Ritter is far from welcoming. He begrudgingly sets them up in a nearby grotto, emphasizing the island’s harsh conditions. The interactions between the two couples are tense and unwelcoming.
A film without a point of identification
Howard has stated that Eden is based on conflicting accounts of the events it depicts, and this ambiguity permeates the film. The audience is kept at arm’s length, observing the characters as if they were part of an insect colony. The film also features an abundance of wildlife, including crabs, wild pigs, and a full-frontal Jude Law.
The wild card
The arrival of Eloise Bosquet de Wagner Wehrhorn, played by Ana de Armas, adds a new dimension to the story. Known for her roles in Knives Out and Blonde, de Armas portrays the baroness, a party-girl fatale with plans to build a luxury hotel on the island. Her character brings a burst of energy to the film, but even her charisma cannot sustain it for long.
A descent into chaos
As the relationships disintegrate and the film veers into a madcap version of Lord of the Flies, the audience is left unsure of how to process what they are seeing. Howard seems to assume that viewers will simply go along for the ride, but the lack of relatable characters and coherent storytelling makes this a difficult ask.
Final thoughts
Eden meanders without purpose, filled with random, sluggish showboating. Sydney Sweeney’s portrayal of Margaret offers a glimmer of sanity, but it is not enough to anchor the film. As the story spirals into chaos, the audience is left yearning for a return to a world where the characters are grounded and relatable.
For those interested in exploring this cinematic oddity, you can watch the trailer for Eden here.
For more insights into the world of cinema and TV series, stay tuned for our upcoming reviews and analyses.